Critique the shot

[Buckfever]

With the season approaching my efforts have shifted towards shot selection. So I thought what we could try, presenting a shot selection and have that shot critiqued so that we might all benefit from discussion. I think that height, distance and approximate angle would be good as background.

And the critique could be in inches:
High, low.
Left, right

And then maybe a short discussion explaining why.

So here's my last group from tonight. 12 feet up, 12yards, quartering to approximately 23degrees.

[ncboman]

I'm not sure what you're lookin for here.

uh, looks like you killed the deer with any of those shots cept the one that took the ear off. ;D

I may have shot a little lower and under your back arrow perhaps <2 inches, just behind the crease in the tape at the top of the heart or an inch above. Reason, if the deer did happen to load to bolt as I release, the arrow would still catch it where yours are at the most. If it didn't bolt I'd have a little longer tracking job, which I don't mind.

I like to stay a tad low on deer real close esp head turned in my direction. Also an exit in the bottom of the boiler room leaks oil.

[Buckfever]

nc,
your comments are exactly what I'm looking for.

[Twanger]

For quartering to, that looks danged close to perfect. An inch lower would be ideal for me, but that's splitting hairs.